- Methodology article
- Open Access
Genome-wide SNP identification by high-throughput sequencing and selective mapping allows sequence assembly positioning using a framework genetic linkage map
BMC Biology volume 8, Article number: 155 (2010)
Determining the position and order of contigs and scaffolds from a genome assembly within an organism's genome remains a technical challenge in a majority of sequencing projects. In order to exploit contemporary technologies for DNA sequencing, we developed a strategy for whole genome single nucleotide polymorphism sequencing allowing the positioning of sequence contigs onto a linkage map using the bin mapping method.
The strategy was tested on a draft genome of the fungal pathogen Venturia inaequalis, the causal agent of apple scab, and further validated using sequence contigs derived from the diploid plant genome Fragaria vesca. Using our novel method we were able to anchor 70% and 92% of sequences assemblies for V. inaequalis and F. vesca, respectively, to genetic linkage maps.
We demonstrated the utility of this approach by accurately determining the bin map positions of the majority of the large sequence contigs from each genome sequence and validated our method by mapping single sequence repeat markers derived from sequence contigs on a full mapping population.
The recent introduction of Next Generation Sequencing platforms such as the Applied Biosystems SOLiD sequencer, the Roche (454) sequencer and the Illumina Genome Analyzer, has seen an exponential increase in genome sequencing efforts for a wide range of organisms. Over the last 2 years, a variety of genomes such as cow , papaya , cucumber  and the filamentous fungus Grosmannia clavigera , have been sequenced using these platforms. From the short overlapping sequence fragments obtained, it is possible to generate draft genome sequences using various algorithms developed for de novo sequence assembly [5–7]. Despite improvements in the software used in the assembly of small DNA sequences, it is very difficult to build a fully assembled genome using short read sequence data alone. The number of contiguous sequences in the final assembly can vary from tens, to several thousands depending on the accuracy of the primary sequence data, the depth of sequence coverage, the length and number of sequence repeats and the genome size of the organism studied.
Various methods have been developed to position sequence scaffolds on physical or genetic maps to assist in the assembly process. Positional information for assemblies can, for instance, be derived from comparison with genomic sequences of related organisms. For relatively small genomes with limited numbers of sequence repeats, gaps between genomic sequences can be bridged by polymerase chain reaction or cloning strategies.
However, these methods remain expensive and time consuming, and are largely impractical for organisms with relatively large genomes. Until now, for organisms where no close relatives had been sequenced, the positioning of sequence contigs relative to one another has required their anchoring to saturated linkage maps which has largely depended upon the availability of abundant mapped genetic markers such as simple sequence repeats (SSR) and single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) markers.
SNPs are the most common form of genetic variation between individuals, making them very attractive for anchoring genome sequence contigs to linkage maps. Methods for identifying and genotyping these SNPs have developed rapidly in the last few years and, as a result, a variety of SNP genotyping protocols have become available . However, the ability to build high-density SNP assays relies entirely on the current availability of large numbers of SNPs with known genomic coordinates and known allele frequencies. For the majority of species, the development of high-density SNP assays remains a challenge because draft genome sequences, when available, are generated from the DNA of a single inbred individual and, thus, do not readily permit the identification of large numbers of SNPs. Moreover, the cost of complete genome re-sequencing for SNP discovery remains prohibitive for species with large genomes.
A strategy known as 'selective' or 'bin' mapping has been developed, which permits rapid mapping of large numbers of genetic markers to a mapping framework with a low degree of precision, by using only a subset of highly informative progeny individuals [9–11]. Thus, for a given marker, the joint (or combined) genotype of the selected subset of individuals at a locus identifies a unique mapping bin on the genetic map of the organism.
We describe a method utilizing next generation sequencing to score SNPs and anchor assemblies to a genetic map by exploiting the bin mapping strategy, hereafter referred to as the SNP by Sequencing Bin Mapping strategy (SSBM; Figure 1).
Our approach is based on deep sequencing of genomic libraries from selected progeny individuals. The method was tested on a haploid organism [Venturia inaequalis Cooke (Wint.)] and then validated using the diploid plant species Fragaria vesca (the woodland strawberry). The genome of V. inaequalis, a hemi-biotrophic fungus which is a pathogen of apples (Malus × domestica Borkh)  has been estimated to be as large as 100 Mbp . However, a draft de novo shotgun genome sequence assembled from short single-end and paired-end sequence data, despite having a depth of coverage of approximately 100×, covers just under 40 Mbp of unique sequence (JMC, Hüsselmann L and DJGR, manuscript in preparation). The F. vesca genome size, on the other hand, has been estimated to be in the region of 206 Mb . Sequencing of the F. vesca genome has recently been carried out using a range of sequencing platforms . De novo assembly yielded a total of over 3200 scaffolds, of which 272 cover 209.8 Mb.
Using a bin mapping set derived from a genetic linkage map, whole genome re-sequencing was performed on individuals issued from a V. inaequalis population. The validation of our strategy was then performed by re-sequencing individuals derived from a cross between two closely related diploid strawberry species F. vesca and F. nubicola . The relative large size of the Fragaria genome meant that re-sequencing was performed on reduced-complexity libraries in order to maximize the genome coverage at particular locations. The overall objective was to maximize the number of SNPs detected by whole-genome, or partial re-sequencing of selected progeny individuals, and to use the SNPs identified to anchor the draft genome assembly to an existing genetic map using a bin mapping strategy.
Results and discussion
Test of the SSBM strategy on V. inaequalis
Genome sequencing and assembly
Sequencing of the V. inaequalis genome has recently been performed (JMC, Hüsselmann L and DJGR, manuscript in preparation) using Illumina sequencing technology. De novo assembly of a mixture of single- and paired-end sequences was performed using Velvet  and yielded a total of 3088 sequence contigs larger than 500 bp. These sequence contigs totalled 37,685,262 bp with a median size of 2817 bp, an average size of 12,204 bp and a largest sequence assembly size of 220,681 bp. More than 85% of the genome sequence contigs were longer than 10 kb (Figure 2).
Construction of the bin mapping set
Using the selective mapping strategy, eight haploid progeny isolates were selected from a population derived from a cross between isolates C1054 (China) and 01/213 (UK). The framework linkage map developed for this progeny , which covers a total of 804 cM, was divided into 54 bins using eight individuals following the method described previously . The average bin length was 15.5 cM and the longest bin length identified was 31.7 cM. As there were a limited number of individuals selected and because of the haploid nature of the organism under investigation, 13 non-contiguous pairs of bins mapping at different locations in the genome were identified as having identical joint genotypes.
The small genome size of V. inaequalis, coupled with recent improvements in read length and throughput on the Illumina Genome Analyzer platform, have made it possible to use whole genome re-sequencing for SNP discovery and validation. Thus, the genomes of all eight individuals in the bin mapping set were sequenced to a depth in the range of 2× and 6.2×. The total amount of sequence data obtained for each of the eight libraries varied from 80 (library 5) to 251 Mb (library 6; Table 1). Of the 50 bases generated for each sequence, only the first 35 bases were used for sequence alignment and SNP detection. As shown by the Illumina Solexa output files, the raw quality of the bases sequenced following base number 35 started decreasing significantly. Therefore, to avoid the identification of false SNPs and the identification of false joint genotypes, the last 15 bases of each sequence were not taken into consideration.
Sequence alignment and joint genotype detection
Alignment of the 35 bp sequences to the reference V. inaequalis genome was performed with MAQ  using the stringent conditions described in the methods section. Under these conditions, putative SNPs were identified in 2623 of the 3088 unique sequences (85%). High quality SNPs were identified, on average, every 585 bp.
A total of 1232 contigs were identified with at least three joint genotypes each and represented 36,946,609 bp, or 98%, of the assembled genome sequence used in the analysis. The number of identical joint genotypes identified per sequence assembly varied from three to 87, with an average of 10 and a median of seven.
As the V. inaequalis genome sequence used as the reference was different from the two parental strains used in the construction of the bin mapping progeny, the validation of the joint genotype for each sequence assembly was confirmed visually in to avoid the detection of false positive SNPs and priority was given to sequence contigs with a length in excess of 20 kb.
Contig anchoring and validation
Of the 627 sequence contigs which were larger than 20 kb, 514 (82%) were identified as having an unambiguous joint genotype and, thus, could potentially be anchored onto the genetic map. In addition to these, the joint genotype of an extra 440 sequence contigs with a sequence length shorter than 20 kb was also scored. This brought the total number of sequence contigs that could be scored for SNPs in the bin mapping progeny to 954, covering 28,045,768 bp (74%) of the draft genome assembly.
The joint genotype of each of the 954 sequence contigs was then compared to the joint genotype of the pre-determined bins. From this analysis, 666 sequence contigs (70%) were anchored to pre-determined bins, with the remaining 288 (30%) falling into bins that had not previously been identified (Figure 3) because of the restricted marker density on the original linkage map, which was estimated to cover around 70% of the V. inaequalis genome. These new bins were analysed and their position on the linkage map was determined by comparing their joint genotypes with the joint genotypes of neighbouring bins, in between which more than one recombination event was observed. and with the joint genotypes of bins located at the extremities of the linkage groups. This comparison allowed the positioning of 17 new bins (93 sequence contigs) on the linkage map. We also established that eight additional new bins (121 sequence contigs) could be positioned at more than one location in the bin map. Details of the analysis are presented in Table 2. Finally, no potential location could be identified for 19 new bins (74 sequence contigs) which, presumably, lie outside the framework of the current linkage map.
In order to validate our strategy, the map location of 48 SSR markers identified from the V. inaequalis genome sequence (Additional File 1) was compared to the bin location of the sequence contigs from which they had been developed. Of these 48 sequence contigs, 18 were not bin mapped by SNP-seq because the number of joint genotype identified in the sequence did not reach the threshold of three required for validation. Of the remaining 30 sequence contigs, 26 were located in the bin in which their respective SSR had been mapped and four were misplaced. Primer sequences for the 48 SSR sequences are given in Additional File 2. A detailed analysis of the output of the MAQ program revealed that these sequence contigs had been misplaced, mainly because of the low coverage observed for library 5 (Table 1).
Validation of the SSBM strategy on F. vesca
Bin mapping set construction
Six F2 individuals were selected from a mapping population derived from a cross between F. vesca and F. nubicola. The linkage map constructed from this cross covered a total distance of 545 cM and was divided into 55 bins.
DNA fragments of 74 bp were generated by the Illumina Genome Analyzer II, of which 63 bp were used for sequence alignment. Considering that the Alu I fragments isolated represented approximately 10% of the genome, each library thus presented a total coverage of 4.8× to 48× at these particular genomic locations. The final size of data used for the analysis varied from 159 to 1002 Mb (Table 3).
Sequence alignment, scaffolds anchoring and validation
Alignment of the 63 bp sequences to the F. vesca genome was performed using the same stringent conditions used previously. Using sequences derived from the male grand-parental library (F. nubicola), SNPs were identified in the majority of the 3200 scaffolds and one SNP was detected in approximately 25% of the Alu I fragments. Using our approach, 185 of the 211 scaffolds of over 100 kb in length of the F. vesca genome sequence were anchored to the genetic map (Table 4). In addition, 11 scaffolds ranging in size from 4470 to 83,161 bp were also anchored. In total, 92.8% of the Fragaria genome was anchored to the genetic map using the SSBM strategy.
Validation of the contig location was performed by mapping SSR and SNP markers developed from Fragaria sequences. Of the 113 markers developed, 95 (84.1%) were mapped to genomic regions corresponding to the bin location where their respective scaffolds had been anchored. The majority of the remaining markers were mapped to genomic regions corresponding to adjacent bin locations.
In a few cases, SNP identification at regular intervals along Fragaria sequence assemblies allowed us to identify clear changes in joint genotypes within the same assembly. For six of these assemblies, this change in joint genotype did not correspond to a passage from one bin to the next but to a completely different bin located in another part of the genome. Detailed analysis of the assemblies using the SNP data allowed us to pinpoint the location in which the miss-assembly had occurred, thus improving the final quality of the assembled sequence.
Our strategy has shown that it is now possible to anchor genome sequence contigs to a reference linkage map without having to first develop and locate large numbers of sequence characterized genetic markers or undertake the sequencing of bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) ends. This method is ideally suited to organisms for which genetic resources are poorly developed. Using a foundation genetic map, we have developed the possibility of anchoring and ordering genome sequence contigs rapidly, easily and cost-effectively, without the need of prior extensive genetic knowledge of the organism studied.
The anchoring of sequence contigs to bins provides, in most instances, an approximate estimate of the location of a sequence in a particular linkage group but does not allow the relative positioning of sequence contigs within each bin. Thus, the accuracy of the location of each sequence assembly within the map depends entirely on the initial selection of the individuals to be sequenced and on the size of the sequence contigs to be anchored. Sequencing more individuals would eventually eliminate bins with similar joint genotypes and permit the identification of additional bins, therefore leading to an increased precision of the bin mapping. However, the location of large numbers of sequence contigs within an existing genetic map can serve as a robust framework for the anchoring of the genome sequence of an organism without the requirement of a high density physical mapping or well-saturated genetic mapping platform. Once scaffolds have been located to mapping bins, the precise positioning of scaffolds and their orientation relative to the linkage map can be performed in a targeted fashion. Where more precise positioning and orientation is required for a given genome region, individual SNPs can be scored in the entire mapping population from which the bin set was derived and scaffolds can be located relative to the genetic markers used to generate the foundation linkage map.
For larger haploid or diploid genomes, the SNP mapping by sequencing strategy can also be applied, as it is possible to sequence a large number of SNPs across all selected progenies by targeting specific regions of the genome. As demonstrated by our study performed on the diploid genome of F. vesca, this can be achieved by constructing libraries with a reduced complexity using restriction enzymes cutting at frequent intervals throughout the genome.
Furthermore, the SSBM strategy can also contribute to improve the quality of the genome assembly by identifying misassembled fragments through the identification of SNPs at regular intervals. Thus, our strategy provides a way to validate the assembly of large sequence fragments.
As a result of the very high throughput generated by the Illumina Genome Analyzer II, libraries could in the future be indexed and run together within a single lane of a flowcell, thus reducing the initial sequencing costs. Conversely, provided that the organism studied has a relatively small genome size, whole sequencing of a subset of individuals derived from a mapping population, instead of a single inbred individual, could provide sufficient data for the de novo assembly of the organism's genome and for the positioning of sequence contigs derived from the sequence assembly into a genetic map.
Given the flexibility and scalability of this approach, together with its demonstrated power to detect large numbers of high quality SNPs, we expect this method to significantly reduce the time and costs associated with de novo sequencing and alignment of sequence contigs to a linkage map. In addition, it should be possible to undertake this process without the use of an existing linkage map. For relatively small genomes, the sequencing of a larger set of individuals could provide enough data to perform de novo sequence assembly, SNP identification and relative sequence assembly positioning. The use of long mate pair sequencing will result in the generation of much larger de novo assemblies which will, in turn, allow the use of reduced complexity sequencing to provide the SNP-seq bin set data needed for the application of the SSBM strategy to larger genomes. This opens the way for the generation of low cost draft genome sequencing for a wide range of minor crops and pathogens for which funding is usually limited.
DNA was isolated from eight individuals derived from a bin mapping set using a protocol developed by  with modifications from . Purified DNA was then further prepared according to the manufacturer's protocol (Illumina GAII analyzer). Each library was run on a separate GAII lane in order to obtain a maximum coverage of the genome for each individual.
Six F2 individuals derived from a cross between F. vesca and F. nubicola were selected to form the bin mapping set. The larger genome size of this species meant that reduced complexity libraries were constructed using the restriction enzyme Alu I. As for V. inaequalis, purified DNA was further prepared according to the manufacturer's protocol. Libraries were run on separate GAII lanes.
Sequence alignment to reference genome and joint genotype identification
Alignment of the sequences to their respective reference genome was performed with MAQ  using stringent conditions, based on high base quality values (maq assemble: -m = 2; -Q = 70 -q = 20), and using only sequences aligning to the reference genome with less than two mismatches.
Putative SNPs obtained from MAQ were examined over all the selected individuals in order to generate joint genotypes as follows: SNPs identified in the individuals were scored relative to the SNPs at identical positions in the reference strain in order to generate a joint genotype at different locations on the assembled contigs. Contigs were retained for further screening, provided they contained at least three occurrences of the same joint genotype.
single nucleotide polymorphism
SNP sequencing Bin mapping
simple sequence repeat.
The Bovine Genome Sequencing and Analysis Consortium: The genome sequence of taurine cattle: a window to ruminant biology and evolution. Science. 2009, 324 (5926): 522-528. 10.1126/science.1169588.
Ming R, Hou S, Feng Y, Yu Q, Dionne-Laporte A, Saw JH, Senin P, Wang W, Ly BV, Lewis KL, et al: The draft genome of the transgenic tropical fruit tree papaya (Carica papaya Linnaeus). Nature. 2008, 452: 991-997. 10.1038/nature06856.
Huang S, Li R, Zhang Z, Li L, Gu X, et al: The genome of the cucumber, Cucumis sativus L. Nat Genet. 2009, 41: 1275-1281. 10.1038/ng.475.
DiGuistini S, Liao NY, Platt D, Robertson G, Seidel M, Chan SK, Docking TR, Birol I, RA Holt, Hirst M, et al: De novo genome sequence assembly of a filamentous fungus using Sanger, 454 and Illumina sequence data. Genome Biol. 2009, 10: R94-10.1186/gb-2009-10-9-r94.
Butler J, MacCallum I, Kleber M, Shlyakhter IA, Belmonte MK, Lander ES, Nusbaum C, Jaffe DB: ALLPATHS: de novo assembly of whole-genome shotgun microreads. Gen Re. 2008, 18: 810-820. 10.1101/gr.7337908.
Hernandez D, Francois P, Farinelli L, Schrenzel L: De novo bacterial genome sequencing: millions of very short reads assembled on a desktop computer. Gen Res. 2008, 15: 802-809. 10.1101/gr.072033.107.
Zerbino DR, Birney E: Velvet: Algorithms for de novo short read assembly using de Bruijn graphs. Gen Res. 2008, 18: 821-829. 10.1101/gr.074492.107.
Sobrino B, Brion M, Carracedó A: SNPs in forensic genetics: a review on SNP typing methodologies. For Sci Int. 2005, 154: 181-194.
Vision TJ, Brown DG, Shmoys DB, Durrett RT, Tanksley SD: Selective mapping: a strategy for optimizing the construction of high-density linkage maps. Genetics. 2000, 155: 407-420.
Howad W, Yamamoto T, Dirlewanger E, Testolin R, Cosson P, Cipriani G, Monforte AJ, Georgi L, Abbott AG, Arús P: Mapping with a few plants: using selective mapping for microsatellite saturation of the Prunus reference map. Genetics. 2005, 171: 1305-1309. 10.1534/genetics.105.043661.
Sargent DJ, Cipriani G, Vilanova S, Gil-Ariza D, Arús P, Simpson DW, Tobutt KR, Monfort A: The development of a bin mapping population and the selective mapping of 103 markers in the diploid Fragaria reference map. Genome. 2008, 51: 120-127. 10.1139/G07-107.
MacHardy WE: Apple Scab: Biology, Epidemiology and Management. 1996, Minnesota: American Phytopathological Society
Broggini GAL, Le Cam B, Parisi L, Wu C, Zhang H-B, Gessler C, Patocchi A: Construction of BAC clones spanning the region of the apple scab avirulence gene. AvrVg Fung Gen Bio. 2007, 44: 44-41. 10.1016/j.fgb.2006.07.001.
Folta KM, Davis TM: Strawberry genes and genomics. Crit Rev Plant Sci. 2006, 25: 399-415. 10.1080/07352680600824831.
Shulaev Vladimir, Sargent Daniel, Crowhurst Ross, Mockler Todd, Veilleux Richard, Folkerts Otto, Delcher Arthur, Jaiswal Pankaj, Liston Aaron, Mane Shrinivasrao, et al: Whole genome sequencing and analysis of diploid strawberry, Fragaria vesca, a compact and versatile perennial Rosaceous fruit. Nat Genet. 2010
Sargent DJ, Davis TM, Tobutt KR, Wilkinson MJ, Battey NH, Simpson DW: A genetic linkage map of microsatellite, gene specific and morphological markers in diploid Fragaria. Theor Appl Genet. 2004, 109: 1385-1391. 10.1007/s00122-004-1767-9.
Xu X, Roberts T, Barbara D, Harvey NG, Gao L, Sargent DJ: A genetic linkage map of Venturia inaequalis, the causal agent of apple scab. BMC Res Notes. 2009, 2: 163-10.1186/1756-0500-2-163.
Li H, Ruan J, Durbin R: Mapping short DNA sequencing reads and calling variants using mapping quality scores. Gen Res. 2008, 18: 1851-1858. 10.1101/gr.078212.108.
Doyle JJ, Doyle JL: A rapid DNA isolation procedure from small quantities of fresh leaf tissues. Phytochem Bull. 1987, 19: 11-15.
De La Rosa R, James CM, Tobutt KR: Isolation and characterisation of polymorphic microsatellites in olive (Olea europaea L.) and their transferability to other genera in the Oleaceae. Mol Ecol Notes. 2002, 2: 265-267. 10.1046/j.1471-8286.2002.00217.x.
This work was supported by the Deciduous Fruit Producers Trust, the THRIP program of the South African Department of Trade and Industry, the National Research Foundation, and the Claude Harris Leon Foundation.
JMC designed the experiment, sequenced and analysed the libraries and prepared the manuscript. AC designed the PERL script used to extract SNP data. XX and DJS provided the bin mapping population and mapped the SSR markers used in the validation of the method. DJGR was project leader and contributed to the experiment design.
Electronic supplementary material
Additional file 1: . The map positions of simple sequence repeat (SSR) markers identified from Ventura inequalis genome sequence scaffolds on the updated map of Xu et al. . The map was constructed using the methods and data of Xu et al.  with the addition of data for 48 SSRs scored in the full progeny. In total, 45 SSRs located to positions on the seven V. inequalis linkage groups, whilst the three remaining markers were unlinked. (PNG 790 KB)
About this article
Cite this article
Celton, J., Christoffels, A., Sargent, D.J. et al. Genome-wide SNP identification by high-throughput sequencing and selective mapping allows sequence assembly positioning using a framework genetic linkage map. BMC Biol 8, 155 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1186/1741-7007-8-155
- Sequence Assembly
- Sequence Contigs
- Single Nucleotide Polymorphism Discovery
- Draft Genome Assembly
- High Quality SNPs